GoodGuys2GreatMen Video Podcast

What to Do Instead of Arguing About Toxic Masculinity

Dan Dore & Steve Horsmon • 4m 41s • 2 February 2019

Book a free 90 minute strategy call →
What to Do Instead of Arguing About Toxic Masculinity
Video overview: If the toxic masculinity debate leaves you feeling blamed, defensive, or confused about what it even means to be a good man, this one is for you. This video cuts through the outrage and points toward something much more useful — stronger men and women with integrity, empathy, and emotional maturity.

The phrase “toxic masculinity” gets thrown around a lot.

And I understand why a lot of men immediately tighten up when they hear it.

It can feel like another attack. Another accusation. Another way of saying, “There’s something wrong with men.” And if you’re a decent man who has worked hard, cared for your family, tried to do the right thing, and still feels like you’re being lumped in with every ugly male behaviour on earth, it can make you angry.

It can make you defensive.

It can make you want to stop listening altogether.

But here’s the problem.

Most of the public conversation about this stuff doesn’t help anybody become better. It just creates more fear, more resentment, more shame, and more division between men and women who already don’t trust each other enough.

That’s not healing.

That’s just more fighting.

And if your marriage or relationship is already struggling, you don’t need more slogans, blame, or outrage. You need a better way to understand what real strength looks like in a man.

Because the answer is not for men to become smaller, quieter, weaker, more apologetic, or afraid of their own masculine energy.

And the answer is not for men to double down on anger, control, arrogance, emotional shutdown, or “I’ll do whatever I want and she can deal with it.”

Both of those paths create disconnection.

Both of those paths create distrust.

What we need are stronger men.

Not louder men. Not harsher men. Not men who dominate a room because they can’t control themselves. Stronger men.

Men with integrity.

Men who tell the truth even when it costs them something. Men who can hear hard feedback without collapsing or attacking. Men who can feel anger without becoming cruel. Men who can feel sexual desire without becoming needy, grabby, resentful, or entitled.

That kind of man is not toxic.

He is safe.

He is grounded.

He is powerful in a way that doesn’t require anyone else to shrink.

That’s the kind of masculinity I care about.

And brother, if you’re in a painful relationship right now, this matters more than you may realise.

Because your wife or partner is not just listening to your words. She is feeling who you are when things get tense. She is feeling whether you can handle her truth. She is feeling whether you become defensive, dismissive, sarcastic, cold, needy, or explosive when she says something you don’t like.

That’s where trust gets built or destroyed.

Not in the big speeches.

In the moments where your nervous system gets tested.

A lot of men were never taught how to handle those moments. We were taught to provide, achieve, solve, protect, and push through. We were taught how to be useful in the outside world.

But nobody taught us how to stay calm when the woman we love says, “I don’t feel close to you anymore.”

Nobody taught us how to listen without immediately defending ourselves.

Nobody taught us how to be emotionally strong without becoming emotionally hard.

So we do what we learned.

We argue. We withdraw. We explain. We fix. We shut down. We blame her sensitivity. We call her impossible. Or we go the other direction and become so careful, so pleasing, and so afraid of upsetting her that we lose all sense of ourselves.

Neither one feels good to a woman.

And neither one feels good to you.

This video is not about joining one side of a cultural argument. I’m not interested in helping you win a debate on the internet.

I’m interested in helping you become the kind of man who can create more trust, respect, honesty, and safety in real life.

At home.

In your marriage.

With your kids.

With other men.

With yourself.

That requires emotional maturity. It requires empathy. It requires responsibility. And yes, it requires masculine strength.

Real masculine strength says, “I can hear you.” It says, “I can look at myself honestly.” It says, “I can own my impact without drowning in shame.” It says, “I can be kind without being weak, and I can be direct without being cruel.”

That is not easy work.

But it is the work that changes relationships.

When a man starts doing this work, he stops being so easily threatened. He stops needing to prove he is right all the time. He stops treating his wife’s pain as an attack. He stops using defensiveness as a shield against feeling inadequate.

He starts asking better questions.

He starts listening for what is true instead of listening for what he can argue with.

He starts caring more about who he is being than whether he can win the moment.

That is where a man becomes deeply trustworthy.

And the world needs more of that.

Your relationship needs more of that.

You need more of that inside yourself.

Because the real goal is not to become a man nobody can criticise. That’s impossible. The goal is to become a man you respect when things get hard.

A man who knows his values.

A man who can stand in his strength without using it against anyone.

A man who can love, lead, listen, repair, and grow.

That’s what this conversation is really about. Not toxic masculinity as a weapon. Not masculinity as something to apologise for.

Masculinity with integrity.

Masculinity with heart.

Masculinity that makes relationships safer, stronger, and more honest.

That’s worth talking about.

Become the kind of man you respect

If this stirs something in you, you don’t need another argument about what men are doing wrong. You need support becoming more calm, honest, grounded, and emotionally strong in the places that matter most. We’d be glad to help you do that work with other men who are doing it too.

Talk to a coach →

About the Hosts

Steve Horsmon & Dan Dore | Certified Professional Men’s Coach

Steve Horsmon and Dan Dore have spent over a decade supporting good men who are confused, frustrated, and afraid that their marriages and families are falling apart with no idea what to do about it. We've both experienced the same emotions that you're going through now. We know what it feels like to try all the mainstream try harder, be nicer advice while watching things continue to get worse. And that's exactly why Goodguys2Greatmen exists. Since 2012, we've coached thousands of men through some of the hardest periods of their lives; marriage breakdown, emotional distance, sexless relationships, fears of divorce or separation. We focus on practical solutions to help you survive some of the most challenging and painful experiences that a man can go through. This podcast is for men who are done waiting for their life and relationships to improve and are ready to make some bold decisions so that you become more calm and confident and start moving toward what you really want.